March 22, 2016

Tuesday: The Home Stretch!

Hi everybody! Steve M here. That home stretch I'm talking about has to do with the Pairs Competition. Phil and I are ready for Friday. Are you? Well you better because that's the due date. Also, the HJC Podcast is coming up again. If you guys have any questions that you want answered on the podcast then type your question in the comments section below with Podcast Question: in front of it so we know.

So this week I'm going to talk about a former team known as the Columbus Chill. They played in the ECHL during the 1990's and were essential in bringing the NHL to Columbus. They had a really different jersey design, almost like a roller hockey jersey. Let me know what you think of the jersey or if you have any memories of the chill.

Image From columbuschill.net
As a quick reminder:

COTW Mar 13-19 vote (ends Friday @ 11:59pm EST)
Pairs Competition (ends March 25 @ 10pm EST) 
On to the concepts! 
Taylor Roy- Minnesota State Mavericks
Positives: It was a good choice to make a traditional style jersey. A color scheme like this could be problematic with certain designs.
Negatives: The stripe next to the collar on both jerseys that causes a separation with the yoke looks strange. I understand that you wanted to create an illusion of space but it doesn't look like negative space. Also, that purple yoke is just really strange.
Overall: 7.5/10
 Caz Williams-Tampa Bay Lightning
Positives: If this doesn't shout 1990's then I don't know what does. That being said, I really like the hem stripe. the off-set dip towards the left side looks cool. The arm stripes are also nice.
Negatives: Caz, I get the whole 90's feel but the hot pink isn't necessary. Keep the usual colors.
Overall: 7.25/10
Jay Schreyer- Finland (Logo)
Positives: Very regal of you Jay. Putting the flag inside a shield gives it a royal crest feel.
Negatives: It would have been nice to see "SUOMI" instead of "FINLAND".  Also, maybe make the logo itself cleaner. I seems a little blurry like a slightly out of focus picture. But overall it looks really generic. and kind of flat.
Overall: 6.75/10
 Jay Schreyer- Finland (Jersey)
Positives: The stripping is clean but effective enough that it makes the jersey interesting. Probably because of the diagonal stripes on the sleeves instead of going with plain vertical or horizontal. Also, that yoke on the blue jersey is a nice touch. it really changes up the design compared to the white jersey.
Negatives: The sleeve numbers should be higher up on the jersey. they just don't flow well near the cuffs for my liking. I would also suggest you put a border around the Finland Flag on the white jersey because it just looks like to random blue crosses on the yoke for patches. Other than that, it's a nice jersey. I just wish you pushed the logo farther to really give it a wow factor instead of making look like a generic logo on a custom jersey.
Overall: 7.5/10
Dylan Glenn- Buffalo Sabres
Positives: The yellow as the primary color for the jersey really works on this with the simple design. The yellow cuffs give it a bit of a pop at the end even though you would never see it. The plain blue yoke also works well with this jersey. It really pulls it together.
Negatives: The back numbers look to small with the large stripes how high they are. I would move them down a bit to give the numbers and stripping space. Also, make the stripping the same on the sleeves and hem. I don't think the opposite stripping works on this design. You also made a large mistake with the sleeve numbers. when using a one, part of the other number shows up with the one on the sleeve instead of it being perfectly even like other numbers. The numbers could also be tilted to align with the jersey a bit more as well.
Overall: 7/10
Ryan Christensen- Columbus Blue Jackets
Positives: The simplistic design really works here.The large stripe with the single red accent stripe gives it a tradition but modern feel. The yoke on the white jersey was also a smart idea. The white jersey would be just too plain without it. And, as usual, you have a pretty clean design.
Negatives: A hem stripe would be nice with this. It works without it but the jersey could be a lot better with one. That or change the cuff and bottom hem colors like they have on their current jerseys. And maybe a block design for the numbers. The font just doesn't seem to totally fit well, but something a little more traditional should do the trick. 
Overall: 8.5/10 COTW NOMINEE
Lucas Daitchman- Chicago Blackhawks
Positives: First off, if you're trying to prove Steve Grant wrong then I think you might have (sorry other Steve but that's my opinion). The old version of the C with crossed tomahawks with the thick black outline to make it visible looks good on this. Also, the numbers inside that stripe design is a really interesting concept. It reminds me of the old Ottawa Senators jerseys. I would say that this could work as an outdoor jersey (like they need to be in another outdoor game).
Negatives: That chest stripping kills this jersey design. it's way too busy. make the stripping on the sleeves a hem stripe and you've got a good Stadium series jersey. Also, that collar as plain red isn't really working. Add a second color or something.
Overall: 7/10
Lucas Daitchman- Carolina Hurricanes
Positives: Yay the hurricane flag pattern is back! The fact that you made it a darker red also gives it a much cooler look. I'm also loving the three stripe design on the back of the neck on the yoke design for an Adidas jersey. Out of the two jersey the white one is more successful than the red.
Negatives: We've had this talk about adding the stripes on the top of the yoke with the stripes behind the neck already. It just doesn't work on this as well. Also, lose the black bottom on the red as well as on the sleeves and add it into the stripping as a minor deal and the red jersey will look awesome.
Overall: 7.5/10 
Well that's all the concepts for today. If you don't agree with me then that's your deal and I respect it. I'll see you guys next week and good luck to the ones who entered into the Pairs competition with me and Phil. Steve out. 

5 comments:

winnipegjets96 said...

I'll nominate Caz W. for COTW...DAMN thats A E S T H E T I C

Josiah Bosch said...

COTW to Caz. That's genius.

DBro Alexander said...

The pink in Caz's Lightning concept is totally necessary.

It's a mash up between the 90's Lightning identity, as well as movie posters and the overall aesthetic of the movie Drive.

Burkus Circus said...

I don't remember anything about the Chill (I was born in 2002; Chill left Columbus in 1999 to make way for the best team that always just misses the playoffs in the NHL [Columbus]), but I did read a book about them (Chill Factor: How a Minor-League Hockey Team Cahnged a City Forever by David Paitson and Craig Merz, definitely a must read if you like hockey or live in Ohio), and apparently the craziness didn't end with the jerseys. Their Zamboni was painted like an enlarged brain on it and had "Scream 'til your brain hurts!" in a Comic Sans-like font. One of their players wore 101 as an advertisement for the radio station (CD 101) that broadcasted the games. They had an actual fat lady sing the Chill Chant when the clock was winding down and the Chill was winning. They changed their name to the Mad Cows for one game a made every TV station in Columbus think they were passing their name on to the now-Blue Jackets. They had a "Turn back the clock" game the night of the time change in 1994 where the players wore Roman Numerals instead of regular numbers. They had crazy marketing campaigns. They were once triple-booked with a horse race and a dance competition (Not intentionally of course). There's SO MUCH MORE!!! And they won Columbus an NHL team! Thank you Chill!

COTW to the Chill.

GO JACKETS!!! GO MONSTERS!!! GO BUCKS!!! GO CHILL!!!

Caz said...

Thank you all. I know that look isn't for everyone, but I'm glad to see that I could hit emotional note I was going for.

For full effect (and to know where my head was at when I made this) view the concept with Kavinsky's "Nightcall" in the background.

DBro knows what I'm talking about.

Steven, I know the pink is jarring, but without it the purpose is defeated. I thought that the title would explain, but I probably needed to include the poster that inspired me (and that I pulled the colors off of) to show where the thought was coming from.

http://imgs.abduzeedo.com/files/articles/drive-poster/drive_poster_abdu.jpg